Congress shapes science funding through three distinct powers: authorization, which sets an agency's mandate and proposed funding levels; appropriations, which is the separate step of actually allocating money agencies can spend; and oversight, which involves hearings and reviews of whether agencies are following their mandate. The hosts explain that authorizing a funding level does not guarantee that money is appropriated, using the CHIPS and Science Act as an example where appropriated funds for semiconductors differed from broader research authorizations. They also describe how committees and subcommittees divide this work, and note Senate-only confirmation power over agency leadership nominees.
- 01
The hosts flag an ongoing dispute over a White House Office of Management and Budget memo that would let political appointees have more direct input into individual grant decisions, a departure from peer-review-driven agency processes.
- 02
They frame this as a constitutional tension between Congress's power of the purse and the executive branch's claim to set funding priorities during implementation.
- 03
Senate confirmation of agency leaders is mentioned with the example of a new NASA administrator having gone through that process.
1,149 words · auto-generated from the episode video
20:01Now let's look at what can they actually do in the House and Senate that shapes research funding for the work of scientific institutions. Congress has 3 main jobs: authorization, appropriations, and oversight. first, authorization establishes what agencies and programs are supposed to do. They can initiate a research initiative, they can change an agency's responsibility, and they can set out funding levels for that work. But authorizing a funding level doesn't commit Congress to providing that
20:43money. So you can authorize $10 billion for the NSF, but you still need to separately actually ca- like write the check, and these can happen in 2 separate steps. So that actual process of giving the money happens through appropriations. While the provided money a- which is the provided money agencies can actually spend. So you have a use case, like I just mentioned, where you can authorize $10 billion for a research program and then only appropriate 6 Mm or nothing at all. Well. And the Chips and Science Act gives us an example of that distinction. The law provided appropriations, actual money, for the semiconductor in-
21:23industry, but only authorized a broader research expansion for the federal science programs. So when we hear that Congress has authorized billions for research- Yeah we still need to ask how much money it actually has appropriated, um- Okay for a university team for applying for an NSF grant, like we've talked about, uh, those are decisions that help them understand what programs are available and how much research the agency can support, which then dictates the type of work that they do. Um, what's interesting is, you know, Congress authorizes these agencies on what their mandate is, but they generally don't review an individual team's proposal.
22:05That happens through the agency with input from expert reviewers and program staff. Although, there is currently an ongoing battle that is trying to change that paradigm that would then allow political appointees- Right to have individual input and control over- how a large bundle of money that's appropriated for an agency is individually granted to specific programs, which is a massive departure from how this has historically been done. Yeah, and I mean, before historically, the peer reviewers, which were other scientists and other experts in the field of whatever grant proposal was
22:47being deliberated on, they would have some kind of final say, right, on, like You know, uh, because presumably the experts are the ones in charge and know what type of scientific question is worth the money and what is not. And what you're saying here is that, like, in, in very recent times, within the last ad- administration actually, so probably within the last 2 years- Y- yes, and especially this year in particular. Yeah. So this year in particular, just before the midterms, the Trump administration put out, like, a type of memo. Right, which, which, which is how they wanted the White House Office of Management and Budget- Yeah to change how they administered grant funding- Yeah
23:31among other things. Yeah, and this, this is what you mean by the contamination of political activities into fundamental science grants and funding. And it also touches on the tension between the authorities of the legislative branch- Yeah Congress, who has the power of the purse- Mm-hmm versus the executive branch, which is meant to faithfully execute the laws- Right passed by Congress. And part of what the executive branch is trying to do is say, "We get to decide the national priorities of the country at any given time, which means that we as the administ- administrators of the money, uh, should have more
24:12at the political level versus the agency level control over what happens." Yeah. Uh, which is in part, uh, overriding the constitutional authority of the Congress in appropriating the money that the, and what that money should be spent for in terms of the government responsibility. So there's a constitutional issue here, and there's also just some operational day-to-day aspects- Yeah of, of this battle, which is why the midterms kind of mattered as it related to upcoming budget votes over the next 2, 4, 6 year- Yeah cycle. And so we've talked about how Congress, 2 of the 3 aspects of how Congress
24:55wields that power, authori- authorizations and appropriations. What are the 8 federal agencies and their mandates? And here's the money for them to go do that job. Their third tool is oversight, which is then saying, looking at and examining how are these agencies executing on their mandate with the money that they were given to do that mandate. This is something that people see all the time on TV, which is these hearings, as an example, where they'll- Mm-hmm bring in leaders from different federal agencies. Federal agencies span well beyond the scientific agencies we've talked about. This will be the Pentagon. This can be, uh, different finance-related agencies.
25:36There's It's a massive labyrinth. Um, but the focus here is so that members can ask in the context of science research programs, uh, why a research program has changed, how grants are being awarded, whether an agency is following the law, and that would then inform future upcoming- Mm-hmm legislation that might impact that agency. Now, that's for both the House and the Senate. The Senate has also an additional role in deciding who leads these institutions. For positions that require Senate confirmation, which can be the leaders of some of these federal agencies, the president nominates somebody and then
26:17senators decide whether to approve that appointment of who is going to be head of X agency. Uh, an example is, um, uh, the new gentleman at NASA- Yeah Who had gone through this process? So, these are the responsibilities that Congress operates alongside the executive branch. And for supporting science for the members we talked about that will be joining, that can mean a variety of concrete things, right? Helping establish research programs, securing the funding for it, and then holding leadership accountable for how it operates given the amount of new political influence that's happening, uh, in these agencies.
27:00So we've talked about the who, we've talked about the what, what can members of Congress do that impact basic science research? Now I just wanna briefly touch on the how. Um, so how does this detailed work actually happen? Congress divides much of all these groupings of people into committees, which are smaller groups of members of the House or members of the Senate who focus on particular subjects. Within those committees of jurisdiction, there can also be subcommittees that take responsibility for even narrow areas. Mm-hmm. These groups examine proposals, hear from agency leaders, and work on the legislation before it gets to a full-floor Senate or House vote, which is
27:43what's required for it to then become law.
Animal BehaviorScience PolicyResearch Fundingmagnetic fieldsMagnetoreceptionQuantum Biology