The radical-pair hypothesis proposes that birds sense Earth's magnetic field using a protein called cryptochrome 4A in the retina. A blue light photon excites an electron in the protein's FAD molecule, triggering a chemical reaction that produces two molecules with entangled, unpaired electrons. These electrons can exist in a singlet or triplet spin state, and because the two states have different angular momenta, they interact differently with the surrounding magnetic field, producing a downstream signal the bird's brain reads as a visual pattern tied to direction. The hosts note supporting experiments, such as a radio-frequency antenna disrupting bird navigation and a grounded Faraday cage restoring it, but also flag unresolved problems: nobody has directly measured the predicted singlet-triplet oscillation in cryptochrome, the mechanism requires blue light yet birds can navigate in darkness, and blind bats also show magnetoreception.
- 01
The hypothesis was first proposed by physicist Klaus Schulten in 1978, before cryptochrome's role was understood.
- 02
A historical experiment placed birds in a wooden cabin and used a radio-frequency antenna to scramble singlet-triplet oscillations and disorient them.
- 03
Grounding a Faraday cage around the cabin blocked the radio frequency interference while still letting Earth's magnetic field through, restoring the birds' navigation.
- 04
The hosts suggest multiple mechanisms could work together rather than one single monolithic explanation for magnetoreception.
- 05
The chapter closes by introducing a third proposed mechanism, electromagnetic induction, attributed to David Keays.
1,753 words · auto-generated from the episode video
54:33They're in fact macrophages, they're not neurons. Um, classical mechanics and classical electrodynamics might not be everything. So what do you do? You invoke quantum. Qu- the quantum. Yeah yeah. So they went Marvel with this. Okay. And the, the, the original idea was actually proposed in 1978 by a physicist, Klaus Schulten. The idea is to use radical pair quantum mechanism. We're gonna target a specific protein that is found in the eye, in the retina of these birds. It's called cryptochrome 4A.
55:14Here's how it actually works. So you've got this protein, cryptochrome 4A, and it's going to house a molecule called FAD, which is flavin adenine dinucleotide. This is a ubiquitous molecule that is found all over cellular metabolism. It's part of, um, the cellular respiration cycle in the mitochondria, all sorts of stuff. Um, it's found everywhere. It's kind of like a analog of ATP in some sense because it can store energy and then, and then give it back and things like that. Here's what's gonna happen. A blue light photon is going to enter the bird's eye, and it is going to
55:54excite an electron in this FAD cofactor, this light-absorbing cofactor. This photon strike is going to initiate a cascade of electron transfers. The electron's gonna bum, bum, bum, move around, and the process is going to result in a radical pair, which is 2 molecules, the FADH+, and the O2 molecule. Those 2 are gonna each possess a single unpaired electron that's gonna be separated by some physical difference. It's gonna be separated by some physical distance because these are 2 separate molecules, obviously. But here's the thing. They're bound by a shared origin. That's interesting. Right? Yeah. We have seen this before in our quantum mechanics discussions.
56:37Yep yep. Uh- This is an entangled pair of particles. Which is so But it's super radical. It's radical in the sense that the, these are like, uh, radical pairs in chemistry, is what they call it. But in this case, the idea is if I can make the entanglement live on for a while- Yeah I can use that to then sense the magnetic field. That is the idea. And so here's what's happening. These 2 electrons, they're created simultaneously from the same chemical bond. This is good. And now their quantum spins are entangled. Yeah. You've got your Alice and Bob experiment again. But instead in, of like 2 people with little polarizing filters- your Alice and Bob are 2 molecules that each have an electron.
57:20They can exist in 2 distinct states. They can ex- exist in the singlet state or the triplet state. Calling back to our, uh, quantum computing episode, where the singlet and the triplet were the zero and the one of the qubit, in this case, the singlet and the triplet are these 2 states of the 2 electrons that are inside this cryptochrome 4 protein. This was in 1978? He, he had devised it in his head. D- okay. Right? This- Like, and he said that this could be possible. This, that's quite nice. It's quite nice. Because I mean, singlets and triplets had been known for a while. And at the time, cryptochrome had just come out. And people had just started understanding the chemical reactions, right? And, and it's, there's a chance that this could happen.
58:04Because what ends up happening is the singlets and the triplets have different angular momenta. Mm-hmm. Right? Because one of them, they're antiparallel, the other one, they're parallel. So because of these different angular momentum, they're gonna interact with the aggregate magnetic field in a different way. 100%. And when they finally create some kind of signal cascade at the end, because at the end of the day, the whole thing has to like collapse in some sense. Like, there's some other protein that is using the state of these singlet-triplet pr- pairs to then create some kind of downstream- Mm signaling cascade that then goes to the brain to mimic what it means to see something. That's, that's what vision is.
58:44Photons coming in, a signaling cascade going to the brain that's telling us, you know, there's some light over there. If all of that happens, and there's a difference between how the singlet creates a signaling cascade and the triplet, then all of a sudden you have a mechanism to see, literally see the magnetic field of the Earth. Isn't that something? The, the intermediate state ultimately downstream collapses to a zero or a 1 Yeah which then functionally becomes the way in which you can see the magnetic field because of this sort of almost inder- this indirect, uh, detection. Yeah. 'Cause you're not detecting the magnetic field directly. No, you're detecting the singlet versus triplet.
59:26Of, which is impacted- Yeah by its interaction with the magnetic field, which is- Exactly is great. That's great. That's great, right? And, and there's actually a simulation of what the bird's retina would, would see- Mm if they actually w- like, you know, went through it. And, this is 4D. there you go. This- Okay so this is, this is a simulation of what- Oh the bird- Yeah, yeah, yeah would like be looking at. Yeah. And if, if, if it's, if it's heading in the north direction, then it would see a characteristic sort of symmetric arc- Mm-hmm of neural activation, right? The, the white there is not necessarily light. It's some sensation that the bird is getting that those are the neurons that are activated, right?
1:00:07And as the bird turns west or east, the pattern of neurons that are firing in the retina are going to change. And then th- And so it's literally seeing the magnetic field- Field of the Earth. Right. And these, uh, the bird's ability to recognize when I need to go home and, uh, what I'm getting in my neural signaling looks like the image of east, I make it home. Yeah. So it's not east to a bird, but it's this white band- Yeah, it's- Which is so, ah, it's so- Yeah this is- And perhaps, like, perhaps it has learned that this pattern- Yeah means north. Yeah exactly. Because it knows that, like, it, it's noticed that every time the sun rises-
1:00:49Yeah, and I've- the pattern is always this way You know what I mean? Yeah yeah yeah yeah. Like, there could be, there could be innate learning that happens- Yep that correlates this signal to the signal of direction. But at this, at the, the, you need to sense the signal in the first place. We're, we're first, before we get anywhere else, we first need to be able to say, "I can, I can detect the, uh, magnetic field." And this is the mechanism to do so, and then get some output. Then with that, there's a whole variety of other things, but- Exactly. Okay. Yeah yeah yeah. And so, and so this kind of makes sense- Yeah, yeah and because there's a mechanism to it. And people have done experiments, which I'm not gonna show here, but one of the experiments I'll just tell you is, like, they, um, they had like a radio
1:01:30frequency antenna that would mess with the singlet-triplet splitting, okay? And th- they put, they put birds in a wooden box. And when they put this antenna up, that would mess with their- Yep navigation, because the radio frequency itself is messing with the singlet-triplet oscillations that are then leading to this sensation of north versus south. It's the similar concept from the first experiment we talked about. Different- Mm-hmm uh, methodology to interrupt- Yeah the signal, because the way in which it's absorbed is, is different. Yeah. But the same idea of you just, just put a disturbance in the force- Yeah to see does that impact- Yeah, yeah their ability to navigate.
1:02:11And the, exactly. And, and one of the, one of the cool controls that they did at this time was, you know, I told you that they're in s- a kind of wooden sort of cabin that these, these birds are interacting in, and, and they couldn't tell which way is north. Then, um, the researchers put a Faraday cage around the cabin, and they grounded it. So now the magnetic field can go through, the Earth's giant magnetic field can go through, but radio frequency pulses get smeared out by the Faraday cage, and they get grounded. And all of a sudden now the birds could navigate again, right? So- So good it's pointing, it's pointing to this thing, but it's still not enough because we haven't- fully observed the singlet triplet splitting in these cryptochromes.
1:02:53We haven't observed, like, that oscillation. We haven't timed the thing. It would be really nice if we could, like, just stick a cryptochrome here, shine it with a blue light- Yeah, yeah right? Like, or even 2 photons, um, where the 2 photons add up to the energy of the blue light. Does that actually give you the same kind of behavior? There's more stuff that you can do, right? So, so the jury is still out. And the other big problem with this cryptochrome model is that, um, the limitation is you need blue light. You need a blue light photon to excite that radical pair. Mm-hmm. But birds can do this in darkness, in complete darkness. So h- how do you explain that? So how do you explain that, right? This could certainly be one of the mechanisms, and perhaps there are many.
1:03:36But we still haven't explained how bats have magnetoreception. They're straight-up blind- Right but they have magnetoreception, right? And to your point earlier, th- there's this idea that it might be a multi-sensory- Yeah piece. So i-t- it's not saying that it has to be one monolithic- Mm-hmm individual thingy. Yeah. But there's still a little fuzziness here. Yeah yeah exactly. There's still room for more science to happen, right? And, and the third one that I just wanna briefly mention before we get into the liver macrophages of, of this episode, the third one is electromagnetic induction. This is by David Keys. Again, same guy from- Back again? back again. He's back again. So the first thing he did was show that the magnetite materials won't work
1:04:18on the beak. The beak are just macrophages. And now he's back with his own little theory, okay?
Animal BehaviorScience PolicyResearch Fundingmagnetic fieldsMagnetoreceptionQuantum Biology