EP 68 · 1:25:29

Head coils and competing explanations

From Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

Episode
22/24
Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?
In this chapter

Researchers rebutting the liver-macrophage navigation paper use Maxwell's equations to show that the classic 1974 Helmholtz coil experiment could not have reached the liver (only about 1.4% field leakage), so that earlier coil result cannot be explained by a liver-based compass. They also argue the hypothesis fails on neurobiological grounds, since macrophages move around the body and a brain cannot easily integrate a reliable heading from millions of constantly rotating sensors. As alternatives, they propose that killing iron-recycling macrophages causes acute iron starvation or systemic inflammation that disrupts navigation indirectly, without the liver itself being a magnetic sensor, and the hosts stress that the original paper's data (not its causal mechanism) still stands undisputed.

  1. 01

    The original Science cover line only said liver macrophages guide pigeons on cloudy days, without mentioning magnetoreception, which the hosts contrast with how the finding was reported in the press.

  2. 02

    One alternative mechanism holds that destroying iron-recycling macrophages forces the body to scavenge iron for red blood cell production, deprioritizing a separate magnetic-sensing center located elsewhere, such as near the brain.

  3. 03

    A second alternative mechanism suggests macrophage depletion triggers inflammation and pain that selectively impairs high cognitive load navigation systems rather than removing a literal liver compass.

  4. 04

    The hosts compare the current state of magnetoreception research unfavorably to optogenetics, noting no one has traced a full causal chain from a magnetic stimulus to a specific neuron to behavior the way optogenetics did for light-activated ion channels.

  5. 05

    As a hypothetical falsification test, one host proposes adding channelrhodopsin to macrophages so they could be switched on or off on demand during a pigeon's navigation in a lab with a controlled magnetic field.

Transcript

2,037 words · auto-generated from the episode video

1:25:29Right? Now, remember, in that experiment, the Helmholtz coil is attached to the bird's head, and that is what is causing, um, this confusion, because the bird can no longer sense the aggregate global magnetic field. Mm-hmm. So, in this paper, these 2 authors, they go back to that paper, and they, they have the notes, right, about, like, how powerful the current was, what was the size of the current. And now you can just do some of Maxwell's equations and calculate what is the fringe field at the liver. And that's the next n- sort of, um, figure that they have. They're calculating if, if my coil is here- Right and the magnetic field is kinda leaking out, 'cause most of it's gonna be confined to within the 2 coils.

1:26:10But if some of it is leaking out, how powerful is the magnetic field at the liver right? Their point being that im- we, we've shown that when we have this device here- Mm-hmm interrupting the bird's ability to detect the magnetic field, it's not s- the, the leakage is not going to make it the distance to the liver, which is the thing you're saying is the navigation component. Exactly. And so there's, it's, it can't, the, both of these things- Exactly can't be true. Yes exactly. The li- the liver is far enough away- Ah, that's good that, like, the leakage isn't gonna reach there. And it's only gonna be, like, it's only gonna alter the magnetic field there by 1.4%. But the effect that you're seeing is massive. So it can't be that.

1:26:50Yeah. So how, th- that doesn't explain my experiment from 1974. Right bud? And it's, it's the same guy being like, "No, I did this." I, I love this because it's, again, it's, it's, you know, he- He still cares these communities are kind of these, these players- Yeah who, even as they are part of the old guard- Yeah the OGs, they still wanna let the new people know, like- Yeah "Oh, hold on." Yeah yeah. "Young fella." Like, "I did this 50 years ago." Like "Relax." All right? Yeah. It's 'cause you got on that fancy cover. Yeah. Like, you know? Oh, oh, you can do, you, you can do liposomes now and, like, kill macrophages. Like, so what, right? So they also attacked the liver hypothesis for being purely, from a purely

1:27:33neurobiological perspective- Okay because they said, okay, like, let's focus on how the brain would process spatial data, right? In order for the brain to interpret the compass heading, the compass has to be sort of fixed. Like, if I'm in a car and my compass is attached to the dash cam, then as my car moves, the compass is gonna move with it, and then I can know the heading of the, of the car. Yep. Um, these macrophages move around in our body all the time. They are literally, one of their jobs is to move around and look for trash to eat, right? If you're moving around as macrophages all the time, that means your compass is rotating all the time. How do you possibly have a reliable signal from these little tiny compasses

1:28:14that is going to the brain? 'Cause you're saying you have all these distributed compasses with different headings based, based on the position. And, and, and- And then you're gonna- a given time, they have different headings, right? So- And so you're gonna g- then compress it- Yeah to some aggregate- Yeah thingy based on hundreds of thou- 1000000 Yeah whatever. Like no. No. This doesn't- It doesn't work too much compute. Yeah yeah. It doesn't work. It's, it's too much compute, and it's moving around too fast. Like, the, the direction is gonna be changing. How do you keep track of, oh, like, is this macrophage now also telling the brain, "Oh, I was here when I made that, uh, measurement, but now I'm here, and I'm making this measurement"? And then the brain is somehow comp You know, just a bit much. I th- that's also a good one. It's a bit much, right? So th- that is sort of where we're at.

1:28:56And, and all of these authors, they provide alternative explanations, because at the end of the day, you still have to explain- Explain why the cloudy day, um, uh, clod- cauldronate- Yeah uh, yeah, cauldronate- The macrophage killing killing caused, uh, the navigation to just- Yeah. 'Cause that- 'Cause that's a thing and it was very pronounced. Yes. And it happened. And none of these rebuttals are saying that that didn't happen. They're not, they're, they're not doubting the biological data. They're not doual- doubting the biological data. They're simply doubting the mechanism. So they're, they have to propose some kind of alternate mechanism, right? Yeah. Um, so one of the, one of the things that they're talking about is the acute systemic anemia, and this, I think, is probably the best alternative

1:29:39explanation- Okay out of the 2 that they've proposed. Here's the idea. You're wiping out iron-recycling macrophages, right? Yeah yeah. You're, you're, you're killing a bunch of immune cells. Now, what that does is force tissue to iron scavenge, because now there's no, there's no longer, like, the macrophages in your liver that are recycling iron. Now your body is gonna be like, "Give me any iron anywhere in the body, because I need it to recycle it to create more red blood cells." Well, there could be another center in the body is doing the magnetic sensing, perhaps not in the liver. Maybe it's closer to the brain. Maybe it solves all of these other problems.

1:30:20But because now you have put the body in a iron-starved- Right situation- The body's like, "You know what? I don't need the magnetic stuff right now." Right. "I need red blood cells, so I'm g- I'm gonna scavenge any iron that's out there." That actually feels, uh, as, as someone who was born borderline anemic- Mm-hmm uh like yeah. Yeah. Like- It's an off-target effect- Like- in some sense, right? And, and, and so that, that basically the, it Right, an off-target effect. Like, you- you've basically destroyed a key, uh, cleanup mechanism within the body that impacts other functions. And you've not yet- Yeah, 'cause you're killing macrophages. You've not yet, like- In aggregate in the liver, right?

1:31:02Like- Right. Okay And, and effectively the second, the second- Okay um, a- alternative explanation is basically that, which is like you're depleting systemic macrophages. That's gonna trigger inflammation and pain, and selectively impair maybe these high cognitive load navigation systems, right? Both basically effectively different mechanisms- Yeah same idea. The, the first one is a bit more specific in that like, okay, it's like the fact that like I've starved you of iron and now the body's just like, "I just want anything that has iron, even if that's my magnetic sensing mechanism- 'Cause in the hierarchy- of order, it's probably, it's maybe lower than- Yeah others. Exactly. From a survival perspective. Yeah, like I need hemoglobin more than I need to, like, get- Magnet

1:31:43home quickly. Right. Yeah. No. This, this was, this- It's kinda cool this is v- The, the hexagonal diamond- Yeah paper and this liver macrophage paper are competing for the 2 best- Yeah clap back, uh, stories we've covered. Yeah. It's, it's, it's really cool. I mean, this is a, this is a good lesson in just how science is done, right? Which is like people are trying new things, and it was risky for this group to publish that liver macrophages are involved in navigation. They've clearly identified a very stark effect. And so I still think as a science paper it is extremely important, because

1:32:27this gives you a huge amount of information as you go into this field. Even, even the authors that are doing the rebuttal, right, they've learned a lot from reading this paper. Because they've learned that, like, liver macrophages have this huge effect on navigation, which I don't think if you would've asked them before this paper they w- they wouldn't have bet their money that, like, killing liver macrophages would've had this huge effect. But it's clearly a thing, and now this gives you another clue into some of the underlying mechanisms. On the other hand, it's also a kind of word of warning that correlation does not imply causation. Right. animal behavior studies, this is especially- 100% like important and notoriously hard, right?

1:33:08Um, the paper itself is a bit more tame than the press came out, right? Sure. I mean, obviously if you look at the science cover, even in itself, the science cover does not say anything about magnetoreception. The science cover simply says, and I can, I can read it, the science cover simply says, "Liver macrophages guide pigeons on cloudy days." Nothing about magnetoreception. Yeah. That's what they're saying. Uh, th- that's true. Liver macrophages are involved in navigation somehow. Right? Or in at least the lack of liver macrophages- Impacts impacts navigation- Navigation ability in, in a bad way. Right. Right? So, so, um, it's, it's interesting.

1:33:49Like correlation does not involve causation. Um- That's, I think it's, you bring up a good point, which is part of the reason we literally do this show. Yeah. Which is to get underneath the headline- Yeah which usually is not accurately describing, not in the journals, but in the news- Yeah and press coverage, accurately describing what's actually happened. Yeah. This is really great though, because I think one of the things when there's a lot of the back and forth and rebuttals, especially when we can see the peer review file- Mm-hmm is it really, again, it illustrates that this is not a black box, uh, in terms of when we make conclusions that get these splashy paper titles. Yeah. And this was That, that paper that got the cover is still a huge deal.

1:34:31Yeah. And it's clever. Mm-hmm. Uh, the liver macrophages have neurons. It's a gut feeling. I like that. Uh. It, it's kinda clever. I mean, th- they have the steps, right? But as with all of these mechanisms, whether it's the radical pair mechanism- Yes or this liver mechanism, or the inner ear mechanism, right? It's all still up for grabs because no one has shown a clean chain of this chemical does this, which folds this protein, which causes this signal cascade, which then connects to this neuron, which then goes to the navigation system. We have done that for the eye. We have done that for the ear.

1:35:11The magnetoreception is kind of this final frontier of sensation in birds. I wanna ask a, an unrelated question, but, uh, s- in terms of how to think about this. When you talk about making, like, the mechanistic connection- Mm-hmm uh, for, like, internal body stuff- Yeah in this context, 'cause obviously with the eyes and ears, they're sort of these external sensors that are kind of easy to see. Yeah. One of the things we talked about with birds is it, and the mag- the magnetic field, is it could be inside- It could be, yeah, yeah the body. When we talked through our optogenetics story- Mm-hmm and the mechanism, the trail, and the mechanistic process by which we activate, um, the ion channels and we can know when we have the green light, this is exactly what's happening, and we can show- Yeah

1:35:55one, two, three, four, and it's not up for debate- Yeah which is why it got a Nobel Prize. Mm-hmm. Like, that, we're, we're not at the optogenetic level of- No, not at all of, of tracing the process. No. And I'm sure that optogenetics could be used somehow. Like, it could, it could, for example, I'm just gonna make up an experiment now. But it could, like, falsify this one. For example, you could, you could put the, um, light sensitive channels, channelrhodopsin- Yeah on these macrophages. Right? And then, um, like, when the bird is navigating through, like, a lab setting

From the episode
  1. EP 68

    Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

    Do pigeons navigate with their livers? We unpack a surprising study, the scientific rebuttals, and what the midterms mean for research funding.

    Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?

Animal BehaviorScience PolicyResearch Fundingmagnetic fieldsMagnetoreceptionQuantum Biology