EP 68 · 1:19:17

The rebuttals: evidence vs. mechanism

From Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

Episode
20/24
Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?
In this chapter

A coalition of biophysicists, including David Keays, PJ Hore, and Henrik Mortensen, published a rebuttal arguing that the liver-magnetite hypothesis is not biologically wrong but physically implausible. Their case centers on ferritin, the iron-storage protein in the macrophages, whose ferrihydrite core is antiferromagnetic and has a very small magnetic moment. When they calculate the torque this moment would generate in Earth's magnetic field, tens of microtesla, the resulting interaction energy comes out roughly 30 times smaller than the thermal energy present in a warm-blooded bird's tissue, suggesting the mechanism could not reliably respond to the field.

  1. 01

    Hore and Mortensen are described as leading proponents of the radical pair mechanism, a competing quantum-based theory of magnetoreception based in the retina.

  2. 02

    Keays previously challenged an earlier magnetoreception claim by showing that supposed iron-sensing cells in pigeon beaks were actually macrophages, the same cell type now central to the liver hypothesis.

  3. 03

    The rebuttal does not dispute the experimental data on pigeon behavior, only the proposed physical mechanism behind it.

Transcript

537 words · auto-generated from the episode video

1:19:17Where are the haters? Where are the The haters, the haters came out quick. The rebuttals are swift. Okay? I'm gonna go through them one by one. Okay. There's really 2 big ones that I wanna, I wanna go through. The most devastating critique, I have to say, probably originates from a coalition 0 of leading biophysicists, chemists, and sensory biologists. Um, they publish a rebuttal on their website, and their argument is not to dispute the biological data. They're not saying that the experiments are wrong. They're saying that it's probably physically impossible that the mechanism that you are attributing this effect to is really what the, the cause of it

1:19:58is. Now, before we get into, like, the exact arguments here, I wanna just linger on the authors, okay? Okay. These authors are legends of the field that we've talked about just previously. Yes. Keyes, he's the famous guy who- Yes um, did the myth-busting of the macrophage-related errors, right? He said that, "Well, the beaks are actually macrophages." So he's kinda seeing his own work come full circle- Yeah, yeah and be like, "Well, the macrophages are actually the point." So- Clearly, you know, there's some personal, like, "No, I- I- I was right that time. You're using my own argument against me," blah, blah, blah. Um, he's also the guy who, um, is behind the, the inner ear mechanism,

1:20:41There's also PJ Hore and Henrik Mortensen, Mortensen. These 2 are arguably the world's leading champions of the radical pair mechanism. Aha. Okay? So they've got skin in the game too- because they think it's the, it's the thing in the retina- Right with the quantum entanglement stuff. Right, the, the singlet and triplet flip thing. They've got faith with that. Yeah yeah. So, so, so- They're the quantum guys. Yeah, they're the quantum guys, and so they're coming together- and they're like, "Okay, all right. Let's see what Let's see what's up." The enemy of my enemy is my friend. The Yeah. It's like the, the 2 of them have competing theories- Theories. Right right but they're, they're teaming up just to take this person down. This is so good. It's so funny, dude.

1:21:22Um, so this is their contention. Their contention is that ferritin, which is the protein in these macrophages that is giving the ferritin like from ferrous, like iron, this is the protein that gives these macrophages the ability to actually sense the magnetic field. It contains ferrihydrite, which is anti-ferromagnetic. Mm. And that has a very tiny magnetic moment, a magnetic moment being, how well do I respond to a aggregate magnetic field? What is the torque that I experience that rotates me into aligning to the magnetic field? It's extremely tiny, this magnetic moment.

1:22:04And so one can calculate how much effect there would be for something that is about the size of the Earth's magnetic field, which is at the level of tens of microtesla. And if that energy, if the energy of that mechanism is greater than the thermal energy involved in living tissue, especially birds. Birds are warm-blooded animals. When you calculated it out, the magnetic interaction energy in Earth's field is 30 times small.

From the episode
  1. EP 68

    Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

    Do pigeons navigate with their livers? We unpack a surprising study, the scientific rebuttals, and what the midterms mean for research funding.

    Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?

Animal BehaviorScience PolicyResearch Fundingmagnetic fieldsMagnetoreceptionQuantum Biology