EP 68 · 27:46

Committees, appropriations and oversight

From Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

Episode
12/24
Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?
In this chapter

Congressional oversight of federal science funding runs through two separate tracks: authorizing committees and appropriations committees. In the House, the Science, Space and Technology Committee handles NSF, NASA, NIST and DOE research programs, while in the Senate those duties split between the Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee and the Energy and Natural Resources Committee. Authorizing committees set policy for these agencies, but the actual funding decisions go through appropriations subcommittees, specifically Commerce, Justice, Science and Related Agencies for NSF, NASA and NIST, and Energy and Water Development for DOE science, making seats on appropriations especially sought after.

  1. 01

    Committee and subcommittee leadership positions (majority chairs versus ranking minority members) shape which funding priorities get discussed before a floor vote.

  2. 02

    The hosts cite the Superconducting Super Collider as a historical example of funding reversal: Reagan-era funding was later ended under Clinton in 1993, despite Clinton urging continued funding, showing science funding support does not split cleanly along party lines.

  3. 03

    The hosts note that science funding is not guaranteed to rise under either party and may compete for attention against other priorities like healthcare proposals in a possible era of budget austerity.

Transcript

1,338 words · auto-generated from the episode video

27:46So for science, it helps to distinguish the committees that shape research policy because sometimes when people talk about the House or the Senate, the image can just be, oh, it's, you know, 100 or 400 plus people all in a room arguing about anything and anything at any given time. Um, and it's a little bit more narrow than that. So in the House, the Science, Space, and Technology Committee has the responsibility for civilian research. That includes the NSF, NASA, and the National Institute of Standards and Technology NIST. Yep. Which NIST works on measurement and standards for all bunch of technology. Mm-hmm. The committee also covers Department of Energy research and laboratories.

28:28In the Senate, those responsibilities are divided differently. The Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee covers agencies including the NSF, NASA, and NIST. The Energy and Natural Resource Committee has responsibilities involving the Department of Energy, science, and national laboratories. These committees can work on, you know, all of these research programs, uh, and how these agencies carry them out. Now, that's on some of the authorization aspects. For appropriations, the funding bills go through appropriations committees. And there, there's an appropriations committee in both the House and the Senate, each of which are divided into subcommittees covering different

29:12parts of federal spending. And so these appropriations committees, they're the ones that actually decide where the money is going. They're, when you say secure the bag- Yeah you want someone on an appropriations committee. Okay, so, like, the appropriations committee is, like, one of the most important and powerful committees in DC. And it's a highly lucrative position to wanna be in. You wanna be on the ap- appropriations committee. Yeah okay. Um, that's absolutely right. In both chambers, funding for NSF-NASA and NIST go through the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies subcommittee. Department of Energy science funding goes through the Energy and Water Development subcommittee. Uh, so for an agency like the NSF, there are multiple groups that have a

29:55role- Yeah On all of these aspects for this. So this is why when you hear these ongoing battles about party leadership or, uh, committee leadership, the- each party will have, if it's the party with the majority, the, uh, majority leader or, uh, ranking member, and then you'll have the minority leader, uh, f- who drive the priorities and the process for what gets discussed at that first stage before we get to a full floor vote. Mm-hmm. So those leadership positions in these committees and subcommittees are a

30:37big driver for what gets oxygen when it comes to ultimately the decisions around authorization and appropriations happening. So as the new Congress gets underway, we will be watching how a new swath of members in the House and Senators change the dynamics of the discussions that are happening in these committees as it relates to where does the future of, uh, basic applied and development, uh, science go in terms of congressional priorities, especially when we have huge financial tensions in the US right now that consumers and the American

31:23people are personally feeling. That's right. There's issues around how corporations, which are also drivers of research and development funding, are spending money, and that needing, wanting to be a priority for the American public. And so are science research appropriations, in what is potentially the beginning of an er- era of austerity, are they gonna be able to get oxygen- Yeah uh, with so many other competing issues? Yeah. I think that's Y- you bring up a good point. It is It's not trivial that just because we have Democrats in charge, science funding is going to go up.

32:03And so, um, science is a bipartisan effort. Historically. Historically. But what that means is it's bipartisan support and also bipartisan, um, not support. I don't know what the word is. But like, you know, like, for example, Ronald Reagan was the one who tried to fund the superconducting super collider in Texas. Bill Clinton, a Democrat, is the one who stopped the funding, right? Um, and sure, you could say that's 30, 40 years ago. Well, you know, um, the nuance is still there. And, um, it's, it's gonna come down to, like, what are the priorities, as

32:45you said. I mean, a big thing that's out there right now is healthcare for all, which is, which is, I think, a great thing. But, like, at the same time, um, does healthcare for all also mean heightened funding for fundamental science that will make healthcare cheaper and better in the future? That's not so trivial. And it's a little bit nuanced because if you're gonna look at this sort of, uh, Medicare for all, healthcare for all, Trump Care for all, whatever your label is for it- Yeah, yeah, yeah um, a big part of that conversation is we don't have the money to pay for it. We're not gonna litigate that argument- Right 'cause I think there's details there. Yeah yeah. That's not for this podcast. But I think your point is important, which is part of what funding the basic

33:26research in science could do is actually lower the cost- Yeah that's not going to be a part of the discussion, if I were a betting man. Exactly. It's not gonna be how it's viewed- Yeah, yeah uh, because it's already viewed as such an expensive thing to accomplish. Yeah yeah yeah. And so th- there are real nuances here. And so as we go into, um, season 3 next year, one of the things I'm looking forward to doing, building on the work that we've been able to get educated on and implement from, uh, AAAS, is funding historical data sets- Yeah and tracking, which you can check out on our website at ffp.com, is more closely looking at the legislative and appropriations process, because we

34:09know many of you as listeners are researchers- Mm-hmm are postdocs, and are being impacted by the yo-yo nature- Mm of this process. And it's a little bit, it's not as covered on other major networks in terms of what's actually happening. Yeah. So, you know, hopefully we can, um, provide some more clarity there as we move forward. And this was a good starting point to create a baseline of what are, what, what is actually happening- Yeah and what are we talking about? And the midterm craziness gave us an opportunity to talk some policy from First Principles. So, with that, we are going to take a quick, quick, shill break, mmmhmm. because we gotta keep the lights on on the pod.

34:52So for those of you joining us for the first time, welcome to the best science show on the planet. The 2 of us here run this as a love letter to the research community. The best way you can support the show is with a like, share, a comment, bring it to Journal Club. Uh, also, uh, if you are listening to the podcast, a 5star on Spotify or Apple is greatly helpful in us reaching more people. For those of you who are Apple Podcast listeners, congratulations, you now have video. Woo. After months of back and forth, a video is now available on any podcast

35:33platform that enables it, including Apple Podcasts. We do, we did see some transition issues for our Spotify listeners for a few hours in the day we made the transition over. So, uh, if you are a Spotify listener, videos are available and back, and it's one of the best ways to watch the show because as we will see in our upcoming deep dive, we, uh, like to look at figures and visualize some of these deeply complex topics. And with that, we are going to transition into our deep dive for today, which is going to be about a controversial research paper on the cover of

36:13Science about how birds use their livers to navigate while flying.

From the episode
  1. EP 68

    Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

    Do pigeons navigate with their livers? We unpack a surprising study, the scientific rebuttals, and what the midterms mean for research funding.

    Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?

Animal BehaviorScience PolicyResearch Fundingmagnetic fieldsMagnetoreceptionQuantum Biology