EP 68 · 36:19

Do pigeons navigate with their livers?

From Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

Episode
13/24
Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?
In this chapter

A May 2026 paper on the cover of Science claimed that iron-rich immune cells called macrophages in pigeon livers are sensitive to Earth's magnetic field and help the birds navigate on cloudy days. The hosts note the claim drew significant skepticism and pushback from other scientists, partly because Science does not publish its peer review process, making it hard to see how reviewers responded. They give background on why magnetoreception is suspected in pigeons at all: the birds can navigate on windy days (ruling out smell) and cloudy days (ruling out sun position), leaving Earth's magnetic field as a likely remaining cue, though homing pigeon navigation is known to be multi-sensory, also using visual landmarks and possibly smell.

  1. 01

    Pigeons have a long history as navigators, used in the Epic of Gilgamesh and the biblical story of Noah, by ancient Rome and Greece, and by Hannibal and Genghis Khan for messages.

  2. 02

    Homing pigeons were used extensively in World War I because they could reliably find their way back after being displaced hundreds of kilometers into unfamiliar territory.

  3. 03

    The central unsolved question is not whether migratory species sense Earth's magnetic field, which is widely accepted, but the specific anatomical location and biophysical mechanism that makes this possible.

Transcript

1,361 words · auto-generated from the episode video

36:19So I first encountered this story because it was on the cover of Science, the journal Science, in May 2026, and it piqued my interest because the headline is there on the cover. It's very weird. It says, "Liver macrophages guide pigeons on cloudy days." That's really weird already because first, why are these birds using their liver to navigate, right? Um, navigation means sensory stuff, like you gotta, like, look where you're going and figure out where you're going. That means the senses, which is usually in the head for birds and mammals and things like that, and also it's a brain thing, okay? The liver is nowhere- in the calculation for me when people say sensory mechanisms.

37:03The other, when you look at the story in great detail, you, you go into the story and the authors are claiming that the liver in these pigeons is sensitive to the earth's magnetic field. That's not on the cover. Okay? But the, the magnetic field part is there on the Max Planck website, the Max Planck Institute for Animal Behavior, and that is absolutely wild. Yeah. Why is the liver sensitive to a magnetic field, and it can sense the earth's magnetic field, which is an extremely weak magnetic field, by the way. And, um, I mean, I had heard about magnetoreception before, which is the idea of, you know, animals being receptive to the earth's magnetic field and using that to navigate, but not in the liver.

37:45That, that's weird. The story came out in May, and I was tempted to do a whole episode on it, right when it came out in May. I mean, it was on the cover of Science and everything. It was all over the news, and at the same time, my skepticism was also triggered because I was like- I hadn't even read the paper- but I'm like, "The liver and the earth's magnetic field, there's a lot going on." I'm- I don't know enough about this, but I know enough to be like, "I'm gonna wait it out." "I don't believe you." I don't, yeah. It's like, it's like maybe, yeah. Like, I'm gonna wait it out and see what people say. And Science is also one of these journals that doesn't, um, publish peer review. Ah. Right? So I can't like, like in nature, I can't like go in and see all the, you

38:25know- The back and forth all the back and forth between the reviewers to see what happened. So I, I really wanted to give it some more time, and the wider community delivered because since its publication, there has been a lot of press and there has also been a lot of clap backs from other scientists in the field. So I'm glad I waited. We love a clap back. Yeah. There's been a lot. Um, in this segment, I wanna talk about this story in some detail because first of all, magnetoreception is, is amazing, right? The idea that you can even sense the earth's magnetic field reliably is kinda crazy. And second, it's a great reminder of how dynamic cutting edge science is. We've done stories like this in the past.

39:06The favorite one is probably the hexagonal diamond story, where you had this back and forth, you had all of this lore of people saying it's not possible, then someone's actually made it. All of the back and forth between the reviewers to actually get it right. In this case, we don't have reviewers, but we do have rebuttals. Um, so it's, it's gonna be kind of a wild ride. So first, let's go over some history, as always. This actually dates back to the time of ancient Egypt and Greece. This is, uh, you know, usually when we say let's go through some history, it's like the past 200 years. Now we're going, like, 4,000 years, okay? Going in the way back machine. Way back, um, the Epic of Gilgamesh.

39:48This is the great Sumerian epic, the first, like, big work of fiction that humanity is known for. The Epic of Gilgamesh, it's a story that involves a great flood, and during that, there's a dove that is used to see if the flood is over. So the dud- dove would, like, go out and scout it out, and then come back to the boat or whatever. This is the same motif that is then used later on in the, um, story of Noah in the Bible, where the story goes that Noah sent out a pigeon to check if the flood was over, and when the pigeon came back with a branch of an olive tree, Noah knew that the flood waters were residing and, you know, he could post up somewhere.

40:30Pigeons then became used for navigation, because it turns out, you know, they can go out and come back to their home. So, ancient Rome, in its heyday, had something like 5,000 pigeons. The ancient Greeks actually used carrier pigeons to release the results of the Olympic Games- Oh, we love that back in the day, and send messages during battle. And obviously, you also have Hannibal and Genghis Khan. These guys all used pigeons to relay messages from one to another. All the- You know who else used pigeons? Who? Pigeon Man from Hey Arnold!, the classic Nickelodeon cartoon. Oh dude. Who was the- Yes man who had all the pigeons.

41:11Uh, you know, and Arnold befriended- Yeah and it was complicated. But it just made me think of, you know me with my classic '90s references. Um- That's a good one Pigeon Man, along with Genghis Khan and Hannibal. Yeah. Users of pigeons for, uh, communication and navigation. Exactly. All the way into the modern era, in fact. World War I, homing pigeons were used extensively in battle because they were so reliable. And this is before the 2way radios and the long distance sort of radio frequency communication of World War II. But back then, the homing pigeons were so reliable because they, they had this uncanny ability to fly back from unknown territory. They were carried in tanks, in ships, in sea planes.

41:53They were pretty ubiquitous. And what was miraculous was you could displace them hundreds of kilometers into unfamiliar territory, and they would find their way back. Okay? How did they even do this? I'm very curious. It's, it's really, it's really quite strange- Yeah and quite miraculous, right? Now, from all of the research that we've done, we've done, we definitely know that it's multi-sensory, right? It involves visual landmarks, probably some type of smell, like olfactory maps. But also, they can do this in windy days, so the olfaction kind of goes away. There's no smell on windy days- Mm 'cause you don't know where the smell- Yeah

42:34is coming from. And they can do it on cloudy days, so they can't tell where the sun is. At that point, they probably use mag- the magnetic field of the earth. This is called magnetoreception, and it serves as a kind of 6th sense. It's the same way that, you know, Boy Scouts use the compass to tell which way is north, and then from there, maybe you can tell on a map where, where you need to h- head to. The central biology mystery here is there's a widespread consensus, right, that migratory species sense the earth's magnetic field. Fine. But how? How does that actually happen, right? Like, what is the- How, Sway? Yeah, like, what, what is the anatomical location?

43:16And, um, what is the biophysical mechanism? There's some biology happening, but it's clearly also a giant physics problem in some sense, because you're trying to sense a magnetic field that is extremely tiny. And that is where this latest paper sort of fits in, okay? So, there's a rich scientific history about just investigating magnetoreception in the first place, and it's gonna be important, because a lot of these players are gonna come in in the end, okay? So, it's important to understand how we even got to this spot.

From the episode
  1. EP 68

    Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

    Do pigeons navigate with their livers? We unpack a surprising study, the scientific rebuttals, and what the midterms mean for research funding.

    Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?

Animal BehaviorScience PolicyResearch Fundingmagnetic fieldsMagnetoreceptionQuantum Biology