EP 68 · 1:22:39

Thermal noise and the physics problem

From Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

Episode
21/24
Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?
In this chapter

The hosts explain the core physics objection to the liver/magnetite compass hypothesis: experiments show these magnetic materials only align reliably at cryogenic temperatures around 12 Kelvin, but a bird's body sits near 300 Kelvin, where thermal jiggling is far stronger and faster than any magnetic signal, flipping polarity in nanoseconds, too fast to be biologically usable. The same temperature mismatch is raised as a reason to also doubt the competing radical-pair quantum entanglement theory of magnetoreception, since quantum coherence would need to survive in that same warm, noisy environment. The chapter ends by introducing a new reanalysis of classic magnetic-sensing experiments in pigeons.

  1. 01

    One host uses the image of a single pebble of sand on a beach being swamped by wind and ocean waves to describe how thermal noise overwhelms the magnetic signal.

  2. 02

    The reanalysis preprint mentioned is co-authored by Charles Walcott, the same researcher behind the original Helmholtz coil pigeon experiments, and Joseph Kirschvink, with Walcott now at Cornell.

  3. 03

    One host speculates that a signal lasting microseconds might possibly be biologically amplified, but says nanosecond timescales are too short to work with.

Transcript

486 words · auto-generated from the episode video

1:22:39smaller than the thermal noise- Yeah, yeah at body temperature. Right. Right? These guys were talking about 12 Kelvin. The body is at 300 Kelvin, right? This goes back to So the jiggling that we're talking about is way larger than any of these ferromagnetic materials in these proteins as they respond to the Earth's magnetic field. It's a pebble of sand on a beach, and we're saying that the pebble of sand is, you know- Yeah a driving detectable thing. Exactly yeah. You're not detecting a single pebble of sand. When there's, like, a breeze- Breeze and there's ocean waves- Ocean waves and all this other stuff, right- Yeah that's coming through. That, that's the main argument.

1:23:20And that, that's a, it's a physics-based argument, right? At physiological temperatures, 300 Kelvin, uh, if your thing only aligns below 12K, your magnetic poles are gonna flip in nanoseconds. Mm-hmm. Which is, nanoseconds is not something that is biologically tenable. Mm. Okay? It's too fast. It's just too fast to sense something that only li- lives for that long. Yeah. Right? If you've got microseconds, perhaps. Perchance. Perhaps there's ways to amplify that signal that only lasts for microseconds, but nanoseconds is, is quite small. Okay. Okay? Especially in a world where you're living at 300 Kelvin and your jiggling is extremely energetic, right? You're bumping into stuff all the time in a warm-blooded animal.

1:24:02So that's the main argument that, that these guys put forth. I think it's a pretty good argument, to be honest. And that's exactly why That, that's the one that I was thinking about when I was like, "Eh, like, birds, 300 Kelvin." Like, I, I'm also It's the same reason why I'm also skeptical about the f- the radical pairs- Yeah thing. Okay? 'Cause the quantum entanglement lasting long enough- To- in an environment of 300 Kelvin, it just doesn't add up to me. Like there's like Unless someone shows me M- maybe someone can show me a back of envelope calculation about how the lifetime of, like, this T2 star, in some sense, in quantum computing language, is gonna last long enough for, like, proteins in my, uh, in a

1:24:43bird's eye to, like, sense that. I don't see it. Anyways, it, it's all about it's, uh, i- in biophysics, w- the biggest conundrum is always temperature. And the jiggling of, of stuff. Everything's jiggling. Everything is, all the time. Now, the next, um, preprint that I wanna talk about that is the rebuttal is this. It's the reanalysis of classical experiments. Um, this is published by Charles Walcott and Joseph Kirschvink. Walcott is the same guy who did the Helmholtz coil- Yeah, yeah on the pigeons. So this is one of the OGs. Um, he's at Cornell right now. Um, one of the OGs that sort of established this entire scientific

1:25:25discipline of birds can definitely sense magnetic fields.

From the episode
  1. EP 68

    Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate

    Do pigeons navigate with their livers? We unpack a surprising study, the scientific rebuttals, and what the midterms mean for research funding.

    Krishna Choudhary and Lester Nare with a pigeon between them and the text GPS IN THEIR LIVER?

Animal BehaviorScience PolicyResearch Fundingmagnetic fieldsMagnetoreceptionQuantum Biology