The discussion covers three research examples that used optogenetics to test causal links in the brain. One study by Ilana Witten, Karl Deisseroth and colleagues targeted cholinergic neurons, a small subset of local neurons, to show their specific role in reward circuitry and cocaine-related conditioning. Another, from Susumu Tonegawa's lab, optogenetically activated a neural ensemble tied to a fear-related experience, a step toward locating a memory engram, though the hosts stress this shows a causal trigger for a behavioral response rather than proof that a complete memory is stored in that one group of cells. A third line of work used optogenetic control of dopaminergic neurons to causally test models of reward prediction error, where the brain compares expected and actual outcomes.
- 01
Ilana Witten, who led the reward-circuitry study, is identified as Ed Witten's daughter and a professor at Princeton University.
- 02
The cholinergic neurons studied make up only about 1% of the local neuron population yet have an outsized role in driving addictive behavior.
- 03
Susumu Tonegawa previously won a Nobel Prize in 1987 for discovering the genetic basis of antibody diversity, and the hosts note he is now pursuing a second Nobel through memory engram research.
- 04
The engram paper discussed was published in 2012 by Liu and colleagues in Nature.
- 05
The hosts explicitly caveat that activating a neural ensemble with channelrhodopsin establishes a causal behavioral link, not that a full memory is physically stored in that specific set of neurons.
605 words · auto-generated from the episode video
59:04based on you know what optogenetics has has given us but a few that I'll go into um first one Elana Whitten >> Carl Daisoth and colleagues Elana Whitten is um Ed Whitten's daughter >> who's now at Princeton University she's a professor there >> okay >> in this particular paper she used optogenetic approaches to investigate reward related circuitry and dissected the role of conurgic neurons that make up only 1% of the local neurons. Turns out they play a very specific and significant role in modulating driving behavior and like addictive behavior like in this particular case cocaine
59:45conditioning. >> Okay. >> Right. So we can we can now start targeting specific neurons and be like yeah this is actually involved in the kind of addiction and things like that. Right? Um, you could also do optical manipulation of hippocample circuits for learning and memory. This one's pretty crazy. One profound application is the search for the memory engram, which is the physical cellular substrate for encoding a specific memory. Like I've got a specific memory that lives somewhere in the brain, right? very famously Susumu Tongawa who is a Nobel Prize winner in his own right in 1987 for the discovery of genetic principles underlying antibbody diversity.
1:00:26>> Mhm. >> He's seeking his second Nobel by searching for the memory engram. >> Good on you. Good on you. >> Yep. He's he's trying what he wants to find is the cellular basis for like stored memories. >> Yeah. >> Okay. In 2012, he published a paper with Lou and colleagues. It's a landmark paper in nature that demonstrates optogenetic activation of a neural ensemble. It's associated with a particular experience that triggers the expression of fear. Okay, this is pretty crazy. >> This is pretty crazy. It's a striking demonstration of the possibility of me like manipulating memory related neural representations. Obviously,
1:01:08>> a lot of weird implications also a lot of clinical implications. for example with PTSD >> things like that right so it is worth being precise about what these experiments establish though like >> you're activating a neural ensemble you've targeted a bunch of neurons and you've activated them using this channel redopsson trick now that does not mean that a complete fully formed memory is literally stored in that population okay because memory is a weird thing depends on distributed networks specific synaptic modifications other brain networks that you might not have targeted what this optogenetics tool is making possible is a causal test that yeah this particular set of neurons elicits a behavioral response. Okay. So
1:01:50I do want to make that distinction. >> That's actually an important one. Yeah. >> Yeah. And then finally the last one I'll talk about is a causal link between manipulating doper dopamineergic activity and prediction and reward and the error from that prediction. Like I predict something if I get it that's good. If I don't get it that's bad. The brain fundamentally is a kind of predicting machine right? >> Oh, are you saying we're just the next token prediction machine? >> Yeah, exactly. Well, this well, this particular paper kind of says that. And actually the model of prediction error is corroborated by some of these optogenetic experiments where what you
1:02:32can do is >> specifically target these dopamineergic neurons >> make them fire when errors happen or when the prediction comes true and see how the circuit adapts. Right? So you can literally now causally test this model of prediction and error in this neural circuit. Mhm. That's very nice. >> You can study much more complicated