The chARGe system, built by Gero Miesenbock, used three separate proteins from the fruit fly visual cascade to make mammalian neurons respond to light, demonstrated in a 2002 paper. It proved cells could be switched on and off with light, but the response unfolded over seconds rather than the milliseconds needed to match real neural activity, with highly variable onset times, and it required ongoing injections of chemical cofactors to keep the three-protein system working.
- 01
The 2002 figure discussed shows onset times ranging from about half a second up to ten seconds after the light turned on, illustrating the system's poor reversibility and inconsistency.
- 02
The hosts frame this limitation as the motivation for turning to microbial photoreceptors, which would later offer a single-protein solution without added cofactors.
579 words · auto-generated from the episode video
21:25>> come on. >> Come on." All right, let's go to the next question. >> Next question. >> Yeah. Um, so here's what Misenbach was known for. He developed this thing called the charge system. It utilized this multi-gene strategy to co-express three distinct proteins from the Drosophila visual cascade. Drosophila is the fruitfly. He took proteins from that visual cascade and he expressed that in neurons and he crucially this he expressed this in mamalian neurons. The problem is the following though. Okay, if you look at figure A and this is the paper that came out in 2002 where he did this, it's already kind of optogeneticy
22:05>> in mamalian neurons already. But the problem is in part A, that's the response of this neuron. So the light turns on when the gray bar ends. >> Look at the response time of this thing. The scale bar down there, that's not milliseconds, that's seconds. Okay, this is on the order of thousands of times the time scale of a neuron. We want things at the millisecond time scale. This is happening at seconds. So this is good, right? You can turn on neurons and turn off neurons, but you don't get the temporal precision. Furthermore, you get a lot of variability. On the right hand side, you're seeing the gray is when the light was off and then it's turned on. Sometimes the response is very quick,
22:46half a second to a second. Sometimes it's very very long all the way to 10 10 seconds later, right? It took a long time >> for all of this to to accumulate and then that neuron to turn on in panel B. >> And and so this is the the it's like a diet version of ultimately what happened in in terms of it didn't have the precision from a time perspective. It didn't also have for the reversibility piece. It wasn't quite >> you know what it needed to be. >> Exactly. Yeah. Cuz if it if you take this long to turn something on, then like when you turn it off, it presumably it's going to take very long time to turn off as well, right? And the other thing it required three proteins to go in. It also required co-actors which are like things that bind to the protein to
23:27enable like there's all these working parts that are going in to create it. It's the first time though. It's 2002 so this is very early, right? It's quite >> early and that's why he he's been given many awards. It's not the Nobels this time. >> That's so tough, >> you know. That is tough. That's tough. >> That is tough. Um, and so the challenge now is to create a light control that is genetically targetable and it's fast >> to operate at that >> time scale of neural computation. >> At this point, we it was you're saying there's a chance. We now knew >> we now knew there's a chance, but we got to find the right tool, right? We want a single protein to do the job. We don't want these three different proteins plus I need to inject co-actors. So that
24:08means like in order to keep this thing going I need to keep injecting co-actors right that are going to help this protein out. It's it's not it's not great right >> and the solution comes from a very