EP 61 · 1:06:56

Implications and limits

From Nobel Prize in Medicine 2026 Explained: Optogenetics

Episode
18/18
Watch Nobel Prize in Medicine 2026 Explained: Optogenetics
In this chapter

The hosts weigh the practical and ethical implications of optogenetics, dismissing fears that it could lead to mind control since the viral vectors used to deliver light-sensitive proteins are not something humans are at risk of acquiring. They argue the real concern is that growing understanding of brain circuits, combined with technologies like brain-machine interfaces, could eventually be misused, even while the same understanding offers hope for treating conditions like PTSD by targeting specific memory circuits.

  1. 01

    They note that manipulating memory engrams could offer a path to treating or even erasing past trauma in PTSD patients.

  2. 02

    They raise concern that pairing brain-reading tools like Neuralink with AI could compound risks to mental privacy and autonomy.

  3. 03

    They mention that a question about whether optogenetics could ever probe consciousness was raised at the Nobel press conference, with no clear answer given.

Transcript

404 words · auto-generated from the episode video

1:06:56optogenetics, there were a lot of comments that were saying that this is going to clearly lead to zombies and mind control. Now, I'd like to brace that type of speculation. I don't think optogenetics is going to lead to zombies because I don't think, you know, we're going to get viral vectors in our brain anytime soon. On the other hand, the more we understand about the brain, the more nefarious applications can become. >> So, you know, there is some concern here that that like the memory engrams, right? >> Yeah. Clearly, of course, it's going to be used for PTSD and clinical approaches to understanding trauma and maybe eliminating trauma, past trauma of a

1:07:38individual. That would be the dream. But at the same time, >> you know, with the advent of tools like Neurolink and um AI compounding on the tools like Neurolink, you can imagine a world where things get very scary. Yeah. Right. We've we've discussed on this podcast several brain machine interfaces like the reading inner thoughts. >> Yep. >> Um >> yeah, that was a good that was a good one. >> Yeah. So, you know, putting this in the context of all of the neuroscience that we've looked at, it's both something that gives us hope because optogenetics is an incredible tool that is going to let us understand very nitty-gritty causal links between brain neural

1:08:20circuits and behavior and perhaps even Maybe consciousness. That was another question that was asked during the Nobel Press conference and the person said, "Well, not yet, but maybe in the future." Maybe in the future, right? We'll get some idea. But at the same time, um, you know, we have to be vigilant of all of the other weird things that could happen because we learn more and more about the brain because the brain is really the organ that makes us us. >> Yeah. >> Right. And if we lose control of that, >> if we lose sovereignty over the brain, who are we in some sense? Right. >> Right. So, um I I mean I've been calling optogenetics for a while. Even before this podcast, >> so the first year that we did this

1:09:01podcast, I said optogenetics. I recycled this year and I got it right. >> And so everyone who anyone who said, "Oh, but you recycled." It's because it was correct. >> Yeah.

From the episode
  1. EP 61

    Nobel Prize in Medicine 2026 Explained: Optogenetics

    How did proteins from algae give scientists control over brain cells? We explain the 2026 Medicine Nobel, optogenetics, memory experiments and early medical applications.

    Nobel Prize in Medicine 2026 Explained: Optogenetics

GeneticsNobel PrizeNeuroscience