EP 64 · 56:23

Measuring cosmic neutrino flavors

From Nobel Prize 2026: The Science Gets Stranger

Episode
10/17
Watch Nobel Prize 2026: The Science Gets Stranger
In this chapter

A 2026 IceCube collaboration paper in Physical Review Letters measures the three-flavor composition of cosmic neutrinos reaching Earth, using 11.4 years of data to find a best-fit mix of roughly 30% electron, 37% muon, and 33% tau neutrinos. The hosts explain that cosmic neutrinos are thought to start out from proton-gamma interactions in distant particle accelerators in a 2:1 muon-to-electron ratio with no tau neutrinos, but oscillate between flavors during their journey to Earth, and the detector itself has different sensitivity to each flavor. Comparing the observed near-equal split to the predicted source ratio lets physicists test whether this production mechanism is correct.

  1. 01

    The three neutrino flavors produce distinct signatures in IceCube: electron neutrinos appear as a central burst, muon neutrinos leave a track through the detector, and tau neutrinos show a 'double bang' from decay mid-track.

  2. 02

    The hosts tie this to Raymond Davis's earlier discovery that only about a third of expected solar neutrinos were detected, which was later explained by flavor oscillation.

  3. 03

    IceCube's roughly one-cubic-kilometer size limits event statistics, giving the flavor-fraction measurement fairly large uncertainty.

Transcript

2,599 words · auto-generated from the episode video

56:23higher the energy, the more kind of esoteric physics you can get into. And that's the point. So this next paper, >> it's the ice cube paper from the ice cube collaboration, published in the physical review letters in August 2026. So again, very recent, >> very recent, >> very recent. This is like, you know, 2 months before Ice Cube won the Nobel Prize. >> And it measures the three flavor composition of cosmic nutrinos. The cosmopolitan ice cube of cosmic nutrinos. >> Yeah. Yeah. That's actually that should have been the title honestly. What are you guys doing at Ice Cube? Come on. >> This branding opportunity. >> Yeah. Yeah. So, let's review the

57:03standard model real quick. Here's the standard model. Beautiful. Beautiful. Standard model of particle physics. Everything that is anything except gravity and maybe dark matter and dark energy. I guess if if those things are real. >> So you're saying the majority of the universe. >> Yeah, fair enough. Um um yeah, things that are normal. All right. Things that are normal, >> it's in here. Yes. Okay. At the center and the four that are flanking the center, those are the bzons. At the very center is the Higs Bzon. And the four on the side, those are the gluon, the

57:43photon, and the W and Z bzons. The gluon mediates the strong nuclear force. This is the thing that keeps the nucleus of the atom together. The photon mediates the electromagnetic force like you know electricity, magnetism, light. And the W and Z bzons mediate the weak nuclear force. This has to do with beta decay. And it turns out that you know the photon, the W and Z bzons, they're kind of part of the same sort of gang, the electroeak >> force, >> the weak gang. And the hig bzon is just sort of this enigmatic particle that gives the W and Z bzons mass. Okay. Um

58:23finally on the outer ring those are the stuff that have mass. Okay. Those are the particles that create matter in some sense. Um the top six are the quirks. You've got the up and the down, the charm and the strange and the top and the bottom. Those are those come in those pairs. There's three pairs. And then on the bottom you have the leptons which are the electron and the electron neutrino, the muon and the muon nutrino and the tow and the tow nutrino. >> Crucially those nutrinos come in three different flavors for the three generations of matter. And this is the standard model. Each of these things

59:05actually represents quantum fields. Okay. And the particles are excitations in the quantum field. But the thing that is like fundamental is really like the field of the thing, right? But quantum field theory is very weird and you know I need a few more semesters understanding it before I start talking about it in a bit more detail. >> We love QFT. >> Yeah. In any case, three types of nutrinos, three different flavors of nutrinos. Okay. >> The question that we want to ask here >> is the flavors of those nutrinos, right? that are observed in ice cube. Can we infer something about the physics of the

59:45sources that made those neutrinos by looking at the distribution of the flavors of the nutrinos? >> Okay, because ice cube is going to see this number of electron neutrinos, this number of tow nutrinos, this number of muon nutrinos. Using that numbering scheme, the statistics of that, can I tell something about how the blazars and those weird particle accelerators at the edge of the universe, how those work? I have strawberry, I have vanilla, I have chocolate. If I have more strawberry and then vanilla is the next biggest and then chocolate's the next biggest, it came like it can tell me the source of

1:00:26what produced my cosmopolitan >> ice cream. Yeah. Like what's wrong with the ice cream machine? >> Right. Right. Right. if it's perfectly but again as a being annoying about the analogy but this idea that the the ingredient the proportionality the proportion of the ingredients >> if we take the flavors of ice cream uh tells something about >> the McFlurry machine that made the ice cream the In-N-Out the In-N-Out we're we're from California here we are fans of In-N-Out Burger no sponsorship yet but yo In-N-Out Burger would be a great we're hungry you see how bony we are over here We need a little caloric intake anyway. >> Yeah. So that's the idea, right? We're trying to we're trying to measure the

1:01:06distribution of the types of nutrinos that we see in ice cube. Now, it's useful to separate three different things. Okay? There's the distribution that comes out of the particle accelerator at the edge of the universe. Then there's all of the stuff that happens in between. And then there's the statistics of the ice cube detector itself. Right? We're going to separate those three parts. Let's start with the production. Okay, the production of these nutrinos happens in probably this way. This is how we're guessing. There's a proton that's coming in from these jets. Super high energy. It interacts with a gamma particle, which is a really high beam of high photon of light, high energy photon of light. And when it

1:01:48interacts with that, it's going to create pions. Those pions are going to then decay into muons and gamma particles and electrons and so on and so forth. Let's just look at the the the end of the diagram, the end of the trees where the branches are. Okay, you've got the posetron at the top. Yes. Then you've got an electron neutrino. That's the new E, the V looking thing with the E. That's an electron neutrino. Then you've got an anti-uon neutrino. >> That's the bar. >> And then a muon neutrino. And then the rest are electron positron gamma gamma >> at the bottom. >> Okay. >> Out of the neutrinos, we have two mu nutrinos. >> Yes. >> Two muons. few mu on nutrinos and one

1:02:28electron neutrino, right? So, it's a 2:1 sort of ratio. Okay, let's not worry about the fact that one of them is a anti-utrino and the other one's a nutrino. There's this like there's this weird theory that like the nutrino is its own antiparticle, but we don't know because again, we don't know a lot about nutrinos. But in any case, the signature in our detector would be very similar given if it's a muan nutrino or a anti-muan nutrino. What's really important is the flavor. And in this case, the flavor is a 2:1 ratio. Two muon nutrinos, one electron nutrino. Okay, that's what we're guessing is the starting distribution. >> What's happening at the source? >> What's happening at the source? Okay.

1:03:10Crucially, no tow flavors. >> Yeah, I was going to say where's my where's my umami? >> Yeah, no towel flavors. Okay. Now from the source it's going to come through billions of light years to the earth and during that time it is going to change the mixture because nutrinos mix. They've got these things called mass ien states which you can imagine are like three directions in your Hilbert space of possible neutrino flavors. Okay. Um they're not really even it's it you wouldn't even call them like what's interesting about nutrinos is like the the three relevant

1:03:52directions that you can express what the nutrino is aren't even like electron muon tower. It's like mass one mass 2 mass 3. >> Okay. >> I don't like it. >> Yeah. It's it's weird. Um and and the three flavors are expressed as combinations of these three different directions in some sense. So you can imagine it's kind of like, you know, if you go to the analogy of the ice cream, it's like imagine there's like three ingredients that make up chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, but they come in different like sort of proportions for each of them. >> For each of the individual ones, >> for each of the individual ones, but they're they're like a mystery like box. >> So you could get the dark chocolate or the milk chocolate. You >> But like but like somehow if the milk

1:04:34chocolate and the dark chocolate combine, it gives you strawberry. You know, nutrinos are weird, right? But in any case, these three mass states are mixing all the time. And so sometimes the electrons, >> the electron neutrinos will like transition to tow nutrinos, will transition to muon nutrinos. And one of the famous experiments done by >> the the Nobel Prize winners that discovered the nutrinos, Raymond Davis, >> he discovered that, you know, there's only a third of the nutrinos that we see from the sun showing up in my detector, right? It's like, where are the other two/3? And everyone thought, we went over this in the episode of America 250,

1:05:14>> you know, the John Ball at Princeton was going, "Well, you should be seeing this many events." And he's like, "No, I'm seeing exactly a third of what you're saying." Right? So, what's going on? Turns out there's three flavors and the nutrinos were changing flavor on their way from the sun to the Earth. Okay? So, that's the idea. On the way here, that ratio is going to change. >> Yes. And finally when we get to our detector the detector has a different probability of measuring the three different types. >> Ah okay >> right because it's not like all of these three interactions are created equal. Right. If the tow came in that has a

1:05:54lower percentage of interacting with the ice than let's say the electron neutrino. >> So good thing there's not a lot of towels coming from the source. >> Yeah. Well but we got we don't know. Oh, that's true. Cuz it might theory it it might >> transition on the way on the way. So that's the theory, but it might be the case that it's there, but we just don't on the observational level, we actually are not. Ah, yes. >> Right. So you got to be careful. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Right. Now there's three different signatures for the three different flavors. The electron one just looks like kind of like a single track. >> Um the the the electron was one is in the center. It's not even a track actually. It's more of just like an explosion that happens in the in the center of the detector. The track actually is the muon looking. So the

1:06:35muon nutrino looks like a track >> that like goes through the detector. The electron one is kind of like a central explosion. You can't really tell where it came from, but you've got a really good estimate of the energy because all of the stuff is inside the detector. With the muon, it's like it's coming through. It could have lost energy outside. It could have lost energy on its way out. like but you know where it's coming from because it's a really nice sort of linear thing. And the the tow one has this like double bang idea where like >> bang bang. >> Yeah. It it goes through one and then it transitions in the middle of the detector. It transitions into another particle and then does another um track. I I just

1:07:16>> So, it dumps a bunch of energy and then it has a little bit of energy left over >> and then does I I just want you to know that I just gave a very very famous sports meme that you have no idea about. >> I have no idea what you're talking about >> and people in the comments will know what I'm talking I'm not going to tell you. I didn't mean to. I just couldn't stop thinking about the double bang because double bang is a and in the lexican it's a very specific thing and it's not talking about the town nutrino. >> No, dude. When people in physics when people say double bang, everyone knows you're talking about the town neutrino and you're talking about this sort of double explosion that happens because a decay happens in the middle of the track. Everyone knows that's what you're

1:07:56talking about. >> I'm going to now call the and I'm not going to tell you, but what I'm referencing I'm now going to call it uh the town nutrino uh and make it a thing for the physics who are also sports fan people. Let's make it happen. Uh but not to not to take away from your point here, but there's signatures on the observational level that are very unique and have different uh uh they express themselves differently and they're very distinct. So we know >> uh what flavor we're getting. Exactly. And we are getting some towel because we know that it's the double bang. >> Yeah. Yeah. But those things are quite rare, right? But you have to you have to um scaffold the actual data that you see with the probability that you would see

1:08:37that thing, right? Because like it could be that the thing is actually rare or it could be that like there's a lot of it, >> but it interacting with the ice in my ice cube detector is rare, right? Which one is it? And so you have to do a lot of forward modeling to actually figure out what is the incoming mixture from what you see. there's like a distribution of what you see and from that you build like what is it that is actually coming into the earth from from this source >> the actuality and the possibility are different things >> very much so and so this is what this new analysis did in the physical review letters after 11.4 four years of ice cube data, they figured out the best fit cosmic flavor fractions and it's roughly

1:09:19at about 30% electron, 37% muon, 33% tow. >> Oh, interesting. >> But so it's about a third a third a third and the the error is quite big because there's not that many events. It hasn't been online for that long. And again, we only have a cubic kilometer, right? You've got a bigger thing. you've got more more data and you can constrain this thing a little bit more. But for all intents and purposes, we can use at least this data to create some kind of inference about what's happening at the source. >> And we can tell that we're probably correct about the fact that it's a proton that's interacting with the gamma to create a 2:1 ratio muon electron >> nutrinos.

1:10:00>> Yeah. Yeah. This this is >> but this is this is cool because we're gleaning insight into those particle reactions at the edge of our universe. Th this is um I have so many thoughts about this. It gets back to you know and we'll we'll talk about it in a moment but like why why are we doing this? And so I'll leave that for a moment. But one of the things that we didn't this is just one aspect again paper that came out recently of how we're using this new instrument uh the ice cube nutrino

From the episode
  1. EP 64

    Nobel Prize 2026: The Science Gets Stranger

    How Nobel-winning science leads to vision research, memory-controlled metabolism, cosmic neutrinos and sensors for mirror molecules.

    Nobel Prize 2026: The Science Gets Stranger

ChemistryNeuroscienceNobel PrizeParticle PhysicsAstrobiology